Will Russia’s Isolation Last? – The New York Times

Many international businesses in tech and other industries are stopping work in Russia after the invasion of Ukraine.

It’s not clear how long the corporate solidarity to isolate Russia will last. Just look at past crises.

In 2018, operatives from Saudi Arabia murdered and dismembered the Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi, leading to swift condemnation of the kingdom, which American intelligence agencies found approved the planned assassination. Some, although far from all, foreign companies and tech powers pulled back from business deals with Saudi Arabia.

But within half a year or so, many global companies were back.

The situations in Saudi Arabia and Russia are very different, but both spotlight a problem for global corporations, particularly technology companies whose digital services transcend borders: Should you work in countries where the government’s behavior is unacceptable?

Many American tech executives embraced the belief that economic and cultural interconnections among nations, industries and citizens help prevent conflict and make everyone better off. But as my colleague Patricia Cohen wrote, Russia’s war is the latest challenge to the ideal of global engagement keeping the peace.

Powerful companies — particularly tech companies with their outsize public profiles and wealth — are increasingly under pressure from their customers, employees or elected officials to withdraw their business to push for change to government laws or norms around the world.

Global retailers have been pressured over claims that they profited from forced labor in China’s Xinjiang territory. Opponents of Texas’ abortion restrictions demanded that companies like Uber and Tesla take a stand against the law. Free speech proponents urged Facebook and Twitter to defy the Indian government’s bans on citizens opposing new agricultural laws.

Companies sometimes find themselves in a position to choose principles over profits, with often uncertain odds of systemic change.

After Khashoggi’s killing, some leaders in technology and other industries decided to distance themselves from Saudi Arabia.

Google and Amazon seemed to put on hold negotiations with Saudi government officials to build computer data centers. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation canceled a pledge to a nonprofit led by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, the de facto ruler of the kingdom. The Hollywood agency Endeavor gave back $400 million from Saudi Arabia’s investment fund.

In many cases, international businesses lowered their public profile and resumed ties with Saudi Arabia when the heat died down. There was a lot of potential money at stake.

Updated 

March 13, 2022, 8:06 p.m. ET

Responding to China’s government is the biggest challenge for global companies. Beijing imposed a sweeping national security law in 2020 that brought Hong Kong closer to China’s censorship and covert digital surveillance. Apple, Google, Facebook, Amazon and others responded by threatening to withdraw from the city.

My colleague Paul Mozur told me that tech companies mostly have stayed in Hong Kong, in part because it appears their worst fears — raids on the companies and employee arrests for not complying with the law — aren’t likely. He said the companies continued to evaluate every move or signal from the government.

Each country poses unique challenges for global corporations doing business there. Russia started an unprovoked war on a neighboring country, and most of the world has united behind Ukraine. Businesses’ collective withdrawal from Russia — by choice or, in the case of Facebook, by being blocked by the government — is also different from their absence in long isolated countries like Iran and North Korea.

Karen E. Young, a senior fellow at the Middle East Institute, said that Saudi Arabia and Russia were different in another respect. “The Saudi government and Saudi leadership grasped very quickly the importance of being integrated in international markets,” she said. “Putin seems willing to throw that away.”

Russia-Ukraine War: Key Things to Know

Card 1 of 3

Expanding the war. Russia launched a barrage of airstrikes at a Ukrainian military base near the Polish border, killing at least 35 people. Western officials said the attack at NATO’s doorstep was not merely a geographic expansion of the invasion but a shift in Russian tactics.

American journalist killed. Brent Renaud, an award-winning American filmmaker and journalist who drew attention to human suffering, was fatally shot while reporting in a suburb of Kyiv. Mr. Renaud, 50, had contributed to The New York Times in previous years, most recently in 2015.

Jeffrey Sonnenfeld of the Yale School of Management wrote in Fortune that what he called the “great business retreat” from Russia might lead to a leadership change. He wrote that when international companies cut ties with South Africa decades ago, their actions amplified international government sanctions and helped end the country’s apartheid regime.

Gregory Fairchild, the dean at the University of Virginia’s Northern Virginia campus whose research has focused on corporate strategy and ethics, said that autocratic leaders in Russia and other countries might be calculating that foreign governments and corporations won’t sustain their revulsion and punishments.

“There is a half life to the outrage that is tied to the news cycle,” Dr. Fairchild said. Many leaders “have enough evidence that we wouldn’t care for long.”

Further reading:

The next Theranos trial: Following the conviction of the Theranos founder, Elizabeth Holmes, for defrauding investors in her blood-testing start-up, jury selection is set to start Wednesday in the trial of Sunny Balwani, Holmes’s ex-boyfriend and former deputy, over a similar set of fraud charges. My colleagues David Streitfeld and Erin Woo preview the case and Balwani’s professional history.

The absurdity of being online during a war: “We’re milling about, kind of waiting to see what’s coming, wishing we could do more to stop this stuff,” one sociologist told The Atlantic. (A subscription may be required.)

The college freshman who tracked Elon Musk’s jet around the world now plans to follow the aircraft and yachts of Russian billionaires, Bloomberg News reports. (A subscription may be required.) A related mystery: Does this superyacht belong to a super-connected Russian — maybe even Putin?

You know who loves berries? Hobbes, a lesser kudu (a type of antelope) at a zoo in Cincinnati.

We want to hear from you. Tell us what you think of this newsletter and what else you’d like us to explore. You can reach us at [email protected]

If you don’t already get this newsletter in your inbox, please sign up here. You can also read past On Tech columns.